Compassion Benchmark

Score history

Pakistan

17.2criticalRank #152
26 scored events27 boundary watch cyclesMay 21, 2026August 11, 2026
View entity page →
17.2

Score timeline

Scored
-0.916.3critical

A new rule requires state permission to report outside three cities; the finding rests on one source.

Watchcycle 1
17.2critical

A second independent source corroborating the new foreign-media accreditation rules is the next event to watch.

Scored
-0.916.3critical

More than half of Pakistan's monsoon deaths came from houses collapsing, a building problem, not just weather.

Watchcycle 24
17.2critical

Independent, non-security-source verification of the Balochistan operation's civilian toll is the next event that would move this score.

Watchcycle 23
17.2critical

Independent, non-security-source verification of the Balochistan operation's civilian toll is the next event that would move this score.

Scored
-0.316.9critical

Operation Shaban confirmed Pakistan's existing pattern of disappearances at higher intensity.

Watchcycle 22
17.2critical

Independent, non-security-source verification of the Balochistan operation's civilian toll is the next event that would move this score.

Watchcycle 21
17.2critical

Independent, non-security-source verification of the Balochistan operation's civilian toll is the next event that would move this score.

Watchcycle 20
17.2critical

Independent, non-security-source verification of the Balochistan operation's civilian toll is the next event that would move this score.

Watchcycle 19
17.2critical

Independent, non-security-source verification of the Balochistan operation's civilian toll is the next event that would move this score.

Scored
-1.615.6critical

A Balochistan operation's toll keeps climbing, still reported only by security sources into a fifth week.

Watchcycle 18
17.2critical

Independent, non-security-source verification of the Balochistan operation's civilian toll is the next event that would move this score.

Scored
◆ Hold17.2critical

A Balochistan operation's toll keeps climbing, still reported only by security sources into a fourth week.

Watchcycle 17
17.2critical

Independently verified deliberate targeting of civilians in a cross-border strike would move Pakistan's score down; durable relief for detained protesters and …

Scored
◆ Hold17.2critical

A Balochistan security operation's toll reaches about 129 since July 5, still reported only by security sources.

Watchcycle 16
17.2critical

Independently verified deliberate targeting of civilians in a cross-border strike would move Pakistan's score down; durable relief for detained protesters and …

Scored
◆ Hold17.2critical

Operation Shaaban's toll rises to about 129 since July 5, entirely security-source-reported militant casualties.

Watchcycle 15
17.2critical

Independently verified deliberate targeting of civilians in a cross-border strike would move Pakistan's score down; durable relief for detained protesters and …

Watchcycle 14
17.2critical

Independently verified deliberate targeting of civilians in a cross-border strike would move Pakistan's score down; durable relief for detained protesters and …

Scored
◆ Hold17.2critical

A Balochistan security operation reports a combined 125 militants killed since July 5, atop an already-priced pattern.

Watchcycle 13
17.2critical

Independently verified deliberate targeting of civilians in a cross-border strike would move Pakistan's score down; durable relief for detained protesters and …

Scored
◆ Hold17.2critical

A Balochistan security operation reports 117 militants killed since July 5, atop an already-priced pattern.

Watchcycle 12
17.2critical

Independently verified deliberate targeting of civilians in a cross-border strike would move Pakistan's score down; durable relief for detained protesters and …

Scored
◆ Hold17.2critical

A Balochistan security operation reports 102 militants killed since July 5, atop an already-priced pattern.

Watchcycle 11
17.2critical

Independently verified deliberate targeting of civilians in a cross-border strike would move Pakistan's score down; durable relief for detained protesters and …

Watchcycle 10
17.2critical

Independently verified deliberate targeting of civilians in a cross-border strike would move Pakistan's score down; durable relief for detained protesters and …

Watchcycle 9
17.2critical

Independently verified deliberate targeting of civilians in a cross-border strike would move Pakistan's score down; durable relief for detained protesters and …

Scored
◆ Hold17.2critical

More bodies are recovered in Balochistan showing signs of torture, reinforcing an existing pattern.

Watchcycle 8
17.2critical

Independently verified deliberate targeting of civilians in a cross-border strike would move Pakistan's score down; durable relief for detained protesters and …

Scored
◆ Hold17.2critical

Six more people reportedly disappear in Balochistan, reinforcing the existing enforced-disappearance pattern.

Watchcycle 7
17.2critical

Independently verified deliberate targeting of civilians in a cross-border strike would move Pakistan's score down; durable relief for detained protesters and …

Scored
◆ Hold17.2critical

Mass preventive detention of protesters, a 27-channel media ban, and continued Afghan-refugee deportation reinforce the Critical band.

Watchcycle 6
17.2critical

Independently verified deliberate targeting of civilians in a cross-border strike would move Pakistan's score down; durable relief for detained protesters and …

Watchcycle 5
17.2critical

Independently verified deliberate civilian targeting or a disproportionate mass-casualty cross-border strike is the downgrade trigger. Durable equitable relief…

Watchcycle 4
17.2critical

Independently verified deliberate civilian targeting or a disproportionate mass-casualty cross-border strike is the downgrade trigger. Durable equitable relief…

Scored
◆ Hold17.2critical

First priority-cluster appearance; June 28-29 cross-border TTP strikes on Afghan territory; 36-civilian toll is single-source Taliban claim disputed by Pakista…

Watchcycle 3
17.2critical

Independently verified deliberate civilian targeting or a disproportionate mass-casualty cross-border strike is the downgrade trigger. Durable equitable relief…

Watchcycle 2
17.2critical

Documented deliberate obstruction of monsoon-flood relief is the downgrade trigger; equitable relief scale-up with durable Afghan-deportation reversal is the u…

Scored
◆ Hold17.2critical

First full baseline at 17.2 Critical — monsoon floods (6.9M affected) are exogenous; Afghan deportations and speech law already priced in May 2025 downgrade; s…

Watchcycle 1
17.2critical

Documented deliberate obstruction of monsoon-flood relief is the downgrade trigger; equitable relief scale-up with durable Afghan-deportation reversal is the u…

Scored
◆ Hold17.2critical

HRW June 12 Islamabad forced-eviction (no compensation, defying Supreme Court stay) reinforces Critical-band position.

Watchcycle 6
17.2critical

HRW June 12 forced-eviction report (Islamabad informal settlements, no compensation, defying Supreme Court stay) reinforces Critical position. Cycle 6 hold.

Scored
-0.916.3critical

Army Chief Tampa speech invokes nuclear use; first NUCLEAR-THREAT-RHETORIC methodology flag applied.

Scored
◆ Hold17.2critical

RSF: four Pakistani journalists in exile sentenced to life imprisonment in absentia — transnational repression extending beyond borders. OHCHR April 2026 deman…

Watchcycle 5
17.2critical

RSF May 2026: four Pakistani journalists in exile sentenced to life imprisonment in absentia for 'inciting violence' — transnational repression reaching beyond…

Scored
◆ Hold17.2critical

Critical-band position confirmed. No new May 24-window evidence. Carry-forward: USCIRF refugee expulsion concerns, HRW Afghan deportation surge (146,000+), Ahm…

Scored
◆ Hold17.2critical

Critical-band position confirmed for a second consecutive cycle. USCIRF documented concerns on refugee expulsions and Ahmadiyya attacks; HRW reports 146,000+ A…

Scored
◆ Hold17.2critical

Published Critical-band position confirmed. Ahmadiyya minority targeted under blasphemy laws (documented deaths April–May 2026), 531,000+ Afghan coerced depart…

Scored

Pakistan's published score already sits in the Critical band. The 146,000+ Afghan refugee forcible returns, online speech amendments, and UN HCHR warning are l…